The Fifth Desk · Evaluation

Act I · The Map

Music · Album · 1967 · rock, with the blues and a Weimar cabaret song inside it, opening twice into long improvisation

The Doors

The Doors · produced by Paul A. Rothchild · Elektra · about 44 minutes

The Plate · two sides on ruled floors, each a run of small closed boxes with one low arch among them, then a tall door frame: through the first, a small ripple with two arcs rising over it; through the second, taller, a held line under a ripple that swells wide, collapses and thins to dots

Mode

Los Angeles club rock with the Chicago blues and a Weimar cabaret song brought inside it, opening twice into long improvisation

Mythos

The threshold and the other side; Dionysian fire; the son who kills the father, and the road West

Phase

Eleven tracks on two near-equal sides; on each, short closed songs and then one long open piece, the two long pieces close to half the record

Presentation

Album; eleven tracks, about forty-four minutes, issued by Elektra in January 1967, in the original stereo mix

Register

Organ carrying the harmony and the bass; flamenco, modal and slide guitar; drums with a jazz player’s dynamics; a baritone from croon to scream

Scale

One consciousness at the threshold, wanting out, with eros and death held and the family entered once, as the thing to be destroyed

Governing Proposition

A Los Angeles quartet with no bass player makes its first record a passage through a threshold: two sides of short, closed songs, each ending in a long open piece where the form stops containing and starts to drift, so that eros, intoxication and death are heard as one country, entered through pleasure and found to be the end. A record of real dread and a new dark theatre, whose truth is enacted as mood more than stated.

A Door at the End of Each Side

8.5 / 10
Tier IV · Canonical

Act II · The Essay

Movement I

Break On Through

The record begins with the drums: a bossa nova beat turned hard, under a single figure on organ and guitar, and in under two and a half minutes the first song states the wish the whole record will pursue. It is a wish for passage, through a threshold to the other side, and it is put as an order rather than a hope. The song is a slogan, and it drives rather than rises. Everything that follows on the record will try to say what this opening only names: what the other side is, and what it costs to reach it.

Elektra issued the album in January 1967: eleven tracks on two sides, about forty-four minutes, the first record of a Los Angeles quartet. Jim Morrison sang; Ray Manzarek played organ, piano and keyboard bass; Robby Krieger played guitar; John Densmore played drums. Paul A. Rothchild produced and Bruce Botnick engineered, at Sunset Sound in Los Angeles in the late summer of 1966. The songs are credited to the band as a whole, except two: Alabama Song (Whisky Bar), by Brecht and Weill, from Mahagonny, and Back Door Man, Willie Dixon’s song, first recorded by Howlin’ Wolf. The band had no bass player. Manzarek played the bass line on a keyboard, and a session bassist was added on some tracks.

The architecture is plain once it is seen. Side one holds six tracks in about twenty-one and a half minutes, side two five in about twenty-two and three quarters. Each side is a run of short songs, none over about three and a half minutes, ending in one long, open piece: Light My Fire at about seven minutes, The End at nearly twelve. The two long pieces fill close to half the record. A record whose wish is to pass through a door builds a door at the end of each side, and that symmetry is its form.

Movement II

The Crystal Ship

The third track is the first of the record’s two night-pieces, and the gentlest thing on it. The Crystal Ship is a farewell that is also an invitation into sleep, a lover told to “slip into unconsciousness”, sung with the voice at its most tender over piano. It has a fragile lyric height and the brevity it needs. Its companion on side two is colder. End of the Night takes Blake’s “sweet delight” and Céline’s title and sets them over a slow, reverberant drift with brushes and space in the drums. These are the quiet doors, and the record could lose neither.

What the record discloses can be stated. The ordinary waking world is a room with a door in it, and the self wants through, into eros, intoxication and death, which the record treats as one country. Sound discloses as much as words here, and it is credited as fully: Manzarek’s organ is fairground and church at once, and the record hears pleasure and dread as one sound. The opening song says the wish as a slogan, the night-pieces as farewell, and The End will say it as a rite.

The disclosure is held back by its manner. The condition is enacted as mood and posture, a young man’s romance of transgression, and seldom articulated as a truth that holds once the trance is over. The songs between the doors show the same limit in another form. Soul Kitchen holds its place; Twentieth Century Fox is a sharp, slight portrait of the daylight world the record wants out of; Take It as It Comes restates the urgency of its side without turning it; and I Looked at You, garage pop in the manner of the day, is the one track that could go with ease. They are ordinary rock and pop forms, interchangeable in order, and they are the room the doors are cut in.

Movement III

Alabama Song

The fifth track is a Weimar cabaret song, written by Brecht and Weill for Mahagonny, about the search for the “next whisky bar”, and it is dropped into a rock record from Los Angeles without apology. The organ gives it a fairground lurch, and that lurch turns out to be the record’s sound. It is the nearest the album comes to a disclosure about society, money and appetite in a town, and the words are Brecht’s. It obeys the record’s law better than its origin would suggest.

That law is the night as a place of passage, entered through pleasure and found to be death. Back Door Man, which opens side two, brings Dixon’s blues trickster into the same night, with menace more than elevation and more performance than construction. The furthest element from the law is Twentieth Century Fox, a quick satirical song about a fashionable girl: she is the daylight world the record wants out of, but the song is sung from inside that world, not against it. The range, cabaret, blues, bossa-rock, ballad and drone, is wide and is credit. The law that holds it is a mood more than a physics.

The inheritance was the Los Angeles rock band of 1966, the Byrds and Love, with the Chicago blues and the garage organ combo. The turn was a quartet with no bass player, a drummer whose dynamics came from jazz, a guitarist drawing on flamenco, Indian modes and bottleneck, a cabaret song in a rock record, and a debut that ends in eleven minutes of improvised theatre. The Yardbirds and the Butterfield Blues Band had already opened the long raga and blues form, and organ, blues and drone were common property. The swerve is the darkness and the theatre, made from inherited means.

Movement IV

Light My Fire

Side one ends by opening. Light My Fire begins with a baroque figure on the organ, runs as a song, and then gives itself to two long solos over a fixed vamp, organ first and then Krieger’s modal guitar, rising by accumulation and coming back at last to the figure it began with. This is the record’s warm height, and even here the fire it asks for comes with a “funeral pyre”: eros, on this record, is already turning toward death. A pop song becomes a piece in duration, and the short songs’ tension is let out into it.

Inside the long piece the form is the instrument: the vamp is what lets the solos climb, and the return to the organ figure is what lets the climb end. The recording serves it with restraint. Rothchild and Botnick’s sound is clean, close and live in feel, the band captured largely as a band, and four players sound like a larger thing. Manzarek’s organ carries both the harmony and the bass, a structural solution that is also the sound. The cost of the solution is a thin low end.

The song’s reach was immediate. In an edited form it went to the top of the singles chart, and the album went high in the charts with it. It has been covered across idioms, José Feliciano’s slow version of 1968 the best known, and its organ lines are studied. With it the organ-led dark rock band became a type. The record’s pressure on its field is real and is mostly of tone and of the singer’s role: the means it used, organ, blues and drone, were common, and it changed what a rock band could be more than the language it spoke.

Movement V

The End

The record ends on its longest piece and its summit. The End begins with a tuned tremolo guitar over a drone, then passes into a long, quiet spoken passage in which a figure, the “killer awoke before dawn”, walks through a house, visits sister and brother, and comes to the father’s and the mother’s rooms. The Oedipal crime is enacted, not alluded to. The band rises into frenzy and collapses into quiet. It is real terror held over eleven minutes, and Densmore’s dynamics and Krieger’s guitar are what hold it.

Here the record builds its myth instead of evoking it. Around the house are the snake, the ancient lake and the road West (“West is the best”), and the piece is a rite of passage out of the house into the wilderness. The construction is real, but it is one track, and it is assembled more than fused: the parricide plays as a set piece within the drone. When the piece opened Apocalypse Now in 1979 it was heard as a new work about another war, and what listeners have found in it since, some of it projection its gestures invite, has kept it open. The singer as shaman passed from it to Iggy Pop, to punk’s theatre and to the gothic rock that followed.

Fifty-nine years have kept the record in print and its three best-known songs in broadcast, though it is heard less whole than its songs and its presence is partly the singer’s legend. What it holds is one consciousness at the threshold, eros and death held, the family entered once as the thing to be destroyed, society glimpsed in a fashionable girl and a whisky bar, and labour, history and the state absent. Only The End holds several orders at once. It is the door at the end of the second side, and after it the record has nothing more to say.

Act III · The Twelve

1The Inevitable (Ananke)

Eleven tracks, and the test bites in the middle of each side. Break On Through must open: it states the record’s one wish, passage through a threshold, in under two and a half minutes over a bossa nova beat turned hard. Light My Fire must close side one and The End the record; each is where the short songs’ tension is let out into duration. The Crystal Ship and End of the Night are required as the two night-pieces, the quiet doors. The rest resist the test more than they first appear to. Twentieth Century Fox is a sharp, slight portrait, but it is the daylight world the record wants out of, and without it the doors would open from nowhere; Take It as It Comes restates the side’s urgency, and that urgency is what the long piece releases. I Looked at You, garage pop in the manner of the day, is the one track that could go with ease. The short songs are the room the doors are cut in, compelled by the passage rather than permitted beside it.

Score: 8.3 / 10

2The Unconcealment (Aletheia)

The disclosure can be stated: the ordinary waking world is a room with a door in it, and the self wants through, into eros, intoxication and death, which the record treats as one country. Break On Through says it as a slogan; The Crystal Ship as a farewell, a lover told to “slip into unconsciousness”; End of the Night sets Blake’s “sweet delight” and Céline’s title over a slow, reverberant drift; The End says it as a rite. Sound discloses as much as words and is credited fully: the organ is fairground and church at once, and pleasure and dread are heard as one sound. That is more than a mood: that the wish for release and the wish for death are one wish is a meaning, and it has held beyond the record’s year. What keeps it short of the bar is the manner: the condition is enacted as posture, a young man’s romance of transgression, more often than it is articulated, and much of its truth is left to the trance.

Score: 8.3 / 10

3The Sublime (Hypsos)

Elevation comes often and of two kinds. The dreadful kind is the record’s best: The End, from its tuned tremolo guitar and drone through the long, quiet spoken passage to the band’s rising frenzy and collapse, is real terror held over eleven minutes, and End of the Night is a smaller, colder height. The warm kind is Light My Fire: the baroque organ figure, then two long solos over a fixed vamp, organ then guitar, rising by accumulation and returning to the figure. The Crystal Ship has a fragile lyric height, the voice at its most tender over piano, and Break On Through lifts by drive. Twentieth Century Fox, I Looked at You and Take It as It Comes have energy and no height, and Back Door Man has menace more than elevation. Height on five or six of eleven tracks, but counted by time the record is high for most of its length, since the two long pieces that fill close to half of it are elevated throughout, and at The End very high.

Score: 8.7 / 10

4The Archetypal Deep (Mythos)

Myth is evoked across the record and built in one place, toward which the whole is built. The End builds it: a figure, the “killer awoke before dawn”, walks through a house, visits sister and brother, and comes to the father’s and the mother’s rooms, and the Oedipal crime is enacted, not alluded to; around it are the snake, the ancient lake and the road West. The archetype bears load: the piece is a rite of passage out of the house into the wilderness, and the record ends on it. The sequence bears it too, a threshold at the end of each side, so that the figures evoked elsewhere, the threshold and the other side, the ship of death, the Dionysian fire of Light My Fire, Blake’s night, Brecht’s moon of Alabama, the blues trickster, are stations on the way to the rite. What holds it from the top is that the built myth is assembled more than fused, and the particular, a person with a face and a place, is mostly withheld.

Score: 8.7 / 10

5The Swerve (Parekklisis)

The inheritance is the Los Angeles rock band of 1966, the Byrds and Love, with the Chicago blues the band covered and the garage organ combo. The turn is real: a quartet with no bass player, the bass line played on a keyboard; a drummer whose dynamics came from jazz; a guitarist drawing on flamenco, Indian modes and bottleneck; a cabaret song by Brecht and Weill dropped into a rock record; and a debut that ends in eleven minutes of improvised theatre of parricide and ritual. The stake was a first record by an unknown band, with a seven-minute track and a closing piece no radio could play. There was precedent: the Yardbirds and the Butterfield Blues Band had opened the long raga and blues form, and organ, blues and drone were common property. But the precedent opened a form; this record turned its meaning, away from virtuosity toward darkness, death and theatre, and staked a debut on the turn. The swerve is made from inherited means, and it was a wager.

Score: 8.7 / 10

6The Living Form (Entelecheia)

The sequence is counted here, once. Each side is a set of short, closed songs, mostly under three minutes, ending in a long open piece where the form stops containing and starts to drift: the record knows the threshold by building one at the end of each side. Light My Fire is a pop song that opens into duration; The End is a song that dissolves into rite. Inside the long pieces the form is the instrument: the fixed vamp under the solos, the drone that lets the spoken passage happen at all. Break On Through’s single-figure drive and The Crystal Ship’s brevity suit what they say. The short songs between the doors are mostly ordinary rock and pop forms, interchangeable in order among themselves, but their closedness is part of what the record knows: the room has to be closed for the door to mean anything. The form bears load throughout, and most at the ends of the sides, which is what holds it from the top.

Score: 8.4 / 10

7The Bottomless Well (Apeiron)

Evidence over fifty-nine years, of two kinds. The long pieces have been reused and heard anew: The End opened Apocalypse Now (1979) and was heard there as a new work about another war, and Light My Fire has been covered across idioms, José Feliciano’s slow version of 1968 the best known. The making has been kept open by the band’s own accounts, by a later remix that restored a word cut from Break On Through, and by the long argument over the singer’s poetry. Densmore’s and Krieger’s playing on The End repays close listening, and the organ lines of Light My Fire are studied. Much of what listeners find in The End is projection invited by its gestures, but the gestures invite it because they are open, and the opening has held across six decades of return without being exhausted. What holds the figure is that the shorter songs mostly give what they give at first: the well is deep at the doors.

Score: 8.4 / 10

8Pressure on Tradition (Agon)

The field is the rock album of 1966 and 1967. The intrinsic force is real: the record made a rock band an instrument of dark theatre, organ-led and bassless, with a singer who performs a persona of transgression as a rite, and it showed that a debut could end in long improvised drama. It took the blues and the cabaret song into the same night. That reorganised tone and the singer’s role more than musical language, whose means were common, but tone and role are what the field took from it, and the taking was large. Achieved reach is scored with intrinsic force, and it carries the axis over the bar: Light My Fire, in an edited form, went to the top of the singles chart; the singer as shaman passed to Iggy Pop, to punk’s theatre and to the gothic rock of the late 1970s and 1980s; and the organ-led dark rock band became a type.

Score: 8.8 / 10

9The Imperishable (Aphtharsia)

Survival is weighed over fifty-nine years, and the figure is among the wider for that span. The form is whole: the recording survives as issued and has been in print since 1967, and the word edited out of Break On Through on the first issue is a fault of that release, not a loss of the work. Presence is wide and continuous, with Light My Fire, Break On Through and The End in broadcast for six decades and The End carried to new audiences by film. That presence is popularity in part, and partly the singer’s legend, and the album is heard less whole than its songs; but the songs have carried the album, not replaced it. The fabric is of 1966, the organ and the four-track sound, and the singer’s persona dates more than the music, but little in the surface depends on a technology that has passed, and the record has long outlived the conditions that produced it.

Score: 9.1 / 10

10The Made (Techne)

Command of the recorded medium, with the words weighed elsewhere. Rothchild and Botnick’s recording is clean, close and live in feel, the band captured largely as a band, and its restraint lets four players sound like a larger thing. Densmore’s drumming is the most exact craft on it: the dynamics of The End, the bossa beat hardened on Break On Through, the brushes and space on End of the Night. Krieger’s tuned tremolo and slide and his modal solo on Light My Fire are distinctive and right. Manzarek’s organ carries the harmony and the bass, a structural solution that is also the sound, and there the making is load-bearing. The voice runs from croon to scream. The faults are small against this: the low end is thin, two short songs are routinely arranged, Back Door Man is more performance than construction, and the vocal is at times pushed past control.

Score: 8.6 / 10

11The Inner Law (Cosmos)

One law: the night as a place of passage, entered through pleasure and found to be death. The two most distant elements are Twentieth Century Fox, a quick satirical pop song about a fashionable girl, and The End, an eleven-minute rite, and they obey the same law from opposite sides: the Fox is the daylight world the record wants out of, sung from inside that world, the room before the door. Alabama Song, a Weimar cabaret number in search of the “next whisky bar”, obeys it surprisingly well, and its fairground lurch is the record’s sound; Back Door Man brings the blues trickster into the same night. The range, cabaret, blues, bossa-rock, ballad and drone, is wide and is credit. What holds it: the short songs of side two follow their borrowed genre as much as the law, which is a mood more than a physics, though a mood kept with unusual consistency across that range.

Score: 8.4 / 10

12The Encompassed (Megethos)

Judged on what the record holds, with no discount for the album form. Consciousness is held, the self at the threshold, wanting out. Eros is held in Light My Fire and The Crystal Ship, death in The End and End of the Night. The family enters once and with force, in the father’s and mother’s rooms of The End, as the thing to be destroyed. The sacred is held as rite and evoked as drug; society enters as the Fox and as Brecht’s whisky bar and its money, both glimpsed; the West is landscape, and the natural order a snake more than a world. One consciousness joins what is held, which integrates it and narrows it: the orders arrive song by song, but The End holds several at once, consciousness, eros, death, the family and the sacred in one rite, and that integration is achieved, not attempted. Labour, history and the state are absent, and that is what holds the figure lowest.

Score: 7.6 / 10

Act IV · The Reckoning

8.5 / 10 · Final Average

Placement: Tier IV · Canonical

Strongest Dimensions

The Imperishable at 9.1, then Pressure on Tradition at 8.8, and The Sublime, The Archetypal Deep and The Swerve at 8.7. A record in print and in broadcast for fifty-nine years that has outlived the conditions that made it, a bassless quartet that made a rock band an instrument of dark theatre and set a type the field took up, an eleven-minute closing piece of real terror, a threshold built by the sequence and enacted as rite in The End, and a debut staked on darkness and theatre.

Limiting Dimension

The Encompassed at 7.6: one consciousness at the threshold, eros and death held, the family entered once as the thing to be destroyed, society glimpsed, and labour, history and the state absent. Below the rest, The Inevitable and The Unconcealment at 8.3: I Looked at You is the one track that could go with ease, and the condition is enacted as posture more often than it is stated, which keeps the disclosure short of the summit.

The Necessity Cap clears at 8.3 against a threshold of 7.5, by eight tenths. The Coherence Floor clears with room: The Living Form at 8.4, The Made at 8.6, The Inner Law at 8.4, each against 7.0. The Epochal Gate is unmet on one of five: The Imperishable at 9.1 clears the bar of 8.5 by six tenths, Pressure on Tradition at 8.8 by three, and The Archetypal Deep and The Swerve at 8.7 by two each, but The Unconcealment at 8.3 falls two tenths short. The Universal Minimum is met (no axis but The Encompassed falls below 8.3, against 7.5) and The Encompassed, which is exempted, clears its own floor of 6.0 at 7.6. The summit is closed by the Epochal Gate and by the aggregate. The twelve sum to 102.0, an average of 8.50 that displays 8.5: the work stands at the middle of Tier IV, half a point above the 8.0 at which the tier begins and half a point short of the 9.0 that the summit requires.

Basis · the album as first released by Elektra in January 1967 (EKS-74007), eleven tracks in their original sequence on two sides, about forty-four minutes, in the original stereo mix; judged from knowledge of the recording, its documented making and its reception. The mono issue of the same year is not judged separately. Where later editions differ the first release governs: a remix of 2006 to 2007 restored a word edited out of Break On Through on the first issue, and that change is not credited. Track timings are the commonly listed ones and are given only roughly. Songs are cited by title, and lyrics are quoted only in fragments of four words or fewer. Facts that could not be verified, among them the reason for the edit to Break On Through, the tape speed of Light My Fire on the first issue, the name and share of the session bassist, the length of the sessions, a long track by another Los Angeles band in the same season, and the particular bands of the later gothic rock said to descend from the record, are not given.